U.S. Senators Express Concern About Attacks On Press Freedom In Kyrgyzstan In Letter To President Japarov
Two U.S. senators have written a letter to Kyrgyz President Sadyr Japarov to voice their concerns about recent attacks on press freedom in Kyrgyzstan, including a decision last year to freeze RFE/RL’s bank account.
U.S. Senators Bob Menendez (Democrat-New Jersey) and Jim Risch (Republican-Idaho), who respectively serve as chairman and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, condemned Kyrgyzstan’s use of its “false information law” to crack down on independent media in the letter, in particular its decisions to indefinitely block the websites of RFE/RL’s Kyrgyz Service, known locally as Radio Azattyk, and to freeze the service’s bank account.
“While we recognize the historic role that the Kyrgyz Republic’s leadership has played in upholding the most free, independent media landscape in Central Asia, we are concerned the decisions to block Radio Azattyk websites indefinitely and freeze the service’s bank account jeopardize your country’s international reputation as a beacon of free speech in Central Asia,” the senators wrote in their letter dated January 20.
They said the decisions violate international norms on freedom of speech and freedom of the press, including Kyrgyzstan’s own constitutional guarantees of these freedoms, the senators said.
The Kyrgyz government blocked Radio Azattyk’s websites in Kyrgyz and Russian on October 26 after the broadcaster refused to take down a video about clashes along a disputed segment of the Kyrgyz-Tajik border. The broadcaster was informed on October 31 that its bank account had been frozen.
RFE/RL's President and Chief Executive Officer Jamie Fly condemned the move to freeze the account, saying Radio Azattyk “is a trusted source of news and should be allowed to continue to operate unimpeded.”
RFE/RL last month filed an administrative suit appealing the blocking of its websites.
Menendez and Risch in their letter emphasized Kyrgyzstan’s commitment to uphold freedom of the press as a critical pillar of the U.S.-Kyrgyz Republic relationship. The senators also expressed alarm over reported threats of violence against journalists, including those made against RFE/RL staff during a demonstration in October.
They called on the Kyrgyz government to immediately lift the restrictions on Radio Azattyk, cease attacks on free and independent media, and investigate threats of violence against journalists.
“Recalling your commitment to uphold human rights and the rule of law, we urge you to establish conditions for independent media to freely operate and to ensure Kyrgyz journalists can carry out their work without fear of retaliation,” the senators said.
A number of international organizations criticized the restrictions on Radio Azattyk, and some Kyrgyz cultural and public figures have appealed to authorities to stop the tactics against the broadcaster and to preserve freedom of speech.
Representatives of the Kyrgyz government have denied that the work of the free media is limited in the country.
“Anyone running away from their family in the [North] Caucasus...is never completely safe," according to Elina Ukhmanova, who says she has fled Daghestan after years of violence and abuse from her relatives.
'The Main Mistake Is Trusting Anyone': Woman From Russia's Daghestan Flees Forced 'Treatment' For Atheism, Bisexuality
In August, 20-year-old Elina Ukhmanova fled her home in the Russian region of Daghestan for the third time. She feared for her safety after what she describes as years of violence and abuse from her relatives capped off with several harrowing months undergoing forced “treatment” for atheism and bisexuality at a dubious rehabilitation center in the regional capital, Makhachkala.
Only now, after several months under the protection of human rights activists in an undisclosed location, does she feel safe enough to tell her story.
“Anyone running away from their family in the [North] Caucasus -- it doesn’t matter if it is a young man or a woman -- is never completely safe, even outside of Russia,” Ukhmanova told RFE/RL’s Caucasus.Realities. “Even abroad, there are no 100 percent guarantees.”
Ukhmanova, a college physics student from the city of Khasavyurt, said she remained terrified for some time after activists from the support group SK SOS, which assists LGBT people threatened with violence in the North Caucasus, helped her escape Daghestan.
“I was constantly afraid,” she recalled. “I felt as if they might burst into the room at any moment and force me to go back.”
Ukhmanova’s story is far from unique in the North Caucasus, a patchwork of regions -- most of them predominantly Muslim -- in southern Russia. In October, a young man from Daghestan named Magomed Askhabov complained publicly that the authorities were doing nothing to investigate his allegations that he had been “tortured” at a self-proclaimed rehabilitation center called Start, where he had been sent by his parents to “cure” him of homosexuality.
In late 2021, a gay Chechen woman named Khalimat Taramova alleged that she had been abducted and held for three months at a clinic outside of Moscow called Invia Elite. During that time, she was allegedly subjected to exorcisms and other procedures aimed at chasing away demons. Russian authorities did not react to her claims.
'Beatings And Arguments'
Ukhmanova said her problems at home began when she was about 10, when her mother began instructing her and her younger sister in the daily Muslim prayer rituals.
“I didn’t understand why I needed this, but the adults used force and beatings to force me to pray,” she said. “Any attempt to talk to them just led to more beatings and arguments.”
Around the age of 14, she began to realize her bisexual orientation when she developed feelings for a girl at her school.
“I told my parents about my orientation when I was in college,” she wrote in an essay for the Kholod website. “They started calling me a prostitute.”
Her first major act of disobedience came when she was already a university student in Makhachkala in June 2021. Her department had several days off to prepare for exams, and Ukhmanova concealed this from her parents and did not return home as usual. Instead, she took a job in a café.
“On the very first day, my father called,” she said. “He had found out about the break and knew that other students had come home. I understood that I couldn’t hide from them anymore, so I wrote to my mother and said I was not coming back home…. Together with a boyfriend, we hid in [the Daghestani city of] Kaspiisk. We stayed there for two days.”
At that point, they found out that the police had been questioning their friends. When Ukhmanova called the police, she was told her parents were worried about her, concerned that she intended to join a “terrorist group” or run off to Syria.
The police, she said, told her to come in and write a statement saying that she had left of her own volition and that all was in order. They promised to release her. But when she showed up at the station, she was immediately taken back to Makhachkala and handed over to her parents.
'A Mass Phenomenon'
A few months later, she and her boyfriend ran off again. This time they remained hidden for several months and Ukhmanova was even able to get a passport, potentially enabling her to leave Russia. But in the end, she said, she was discovered by employees of the Alyans Rekaveri rehabilitation center in Makhachkala, working at the behest of her parents. They abducted her, she said, and took her by force to the center for purported treatment.
“Over the four months I was there, there were between five and 10 others,” Ukhmanova said. “Mostly they were drug addicts or alcoholics. Several of them had been in ‘rehabilitation centers’ before and said that they had seen other ‘problematic’ young people like me. They couldn’t say what their ‘problem’ was.”
Ukhmanova added that most of the others at the center had also been abducted against their will.
She said there were no doctors or psychologists at the center. All the staffers were former “patients.” The addicts were, she said, regularly punished by having to do hundreds of push-ups or squats and were sometimes handcuffed to railings in such a way that they had to stand on their toes for prolonged periods.
“Such methods weren’t really used on me,” she said. “Most likely because they knew my parents or because I wasn’t an addict. Mostly they just made me write a lot. Once when I had an argument with another patient, we were handcuffed together for an entire day.”
RFE/RL was unable to contact any representative of Alyans Rekaveri for comment. The center is not registered as a medical organization in Russia. Its website stopped working shortly after Ukhmanova’s story was published.
Ater Ukhmanova’s allegations, the Russian website NewsTracker published comments from an unnamed man who was presented as the center’s director. He claimed all the charges were false and that the center had closed 18 months ago.
At some point after she had been at the center for several months, Ukhmanova’s relatives told her the family planned to send her to an “Islamic education center” in neighboring Chechnya. She had been thinking about running away a third time, but this news made up her mind.
“The day before I left, a neighbor came over to visit my mother, which distracted her,” Ukhmanova said. “I was able to find my passport, which they had hidden. I had been searching for it at every opportunity…. I took this as a good sign.”
In her previous escape attempts, she had confided in friends who were later pressured into revealing information about her whereabouts and plans. This time, she realized she couldn’t do that.
“The main mistake is trusting anyone,” she said. “And the second mistake is thinking you can do it on your own.”
This time, she turned to SK SOS.
“Now Elina is in relative safety,” a spokesperson for the group told RFE/RL. “She is not under direct threat. Many families in the North Caucasus have connections in Moscow and other major cities, so we are not revealing her location.”
In an interview with RFE/RL in October, SK SOS spokesperson Miron Rozanov said “there are quite a few” such rehabilitation centers in the North Caucasus and there have been numerous complaints of LGBT people being abducted and forcibly “treated” at them.
Aminat Lorsanova (file photo)
Aminat Lorsanova, a native of Chechnya, “has told how she was held in a rehab center for several months in 2019,” Rozanov said. “She was forcibly medicated with drugs that affected her cognitive abilities under the guise of treatment for a made-up diagnosis.
But Lorsanova’s allegations never became the basis for an investigation, although thanks to her we learned about the existence of such centers.”
“We can’t say exactly how many there are, but it is a mass phenomenon,” he added, explaining that officially they present themselves as spiritual centers -- which are unregulated -- rather than medical facilities.
Written by RFE/RL feature writer Robert Coalson based on reporting by RFE/RL’s Caucasus.Realities
"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.
RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More
![“Anyone running away from their family in the [North] Caucasus...is never completely safe," according to Elina Ukhmanova, who says she has fled Daghestan after years of violence and abuse from her relatives.](https://gdb.rferl.org/034d0000-0aff-0242-58b9-08daf250c801_w250_r1_s.png)
