Family members of Azerbaijan's transport minister and a prominent Azerbaijani company that does business with the ministry have close ties, raising serious questions about conflict of interest in the ministry's activities.
Transport Minister Ziya Mammadov's son, Anar, and the minister's brother, Elton, are business partners with the members of the family of the founder of the Baghlan Group, a prominent Azerbaijani company involved in major projects in transportation, construction, sports complexes, and oil exploration.
The Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty found that Baghlan was the contractor on a series of major initiatives by the ministry, including the importing of 1,000 London taxis to Baku, the construction of an international bus station, and a lucrative road-construction project.
The group has received preferential treatment and the interlinked companies owned by the families have taken large shares or even monopolized certain transportation sectors like bus transport, taxis, road construction, and cargo-transportation services in the country.
Businessman Hafiz Mammadov, who is not related to the minister, founded Baghlan Group FZCO, which was registered in 2007 in the United Arab Emirates. The ties between the families include co-ownership of the Bank of Azerbaijan and a joint project to build an international bus station in Baku. Both families also have top executives in the Baku Football Club. Companies owned by Anar Mammadov are also listed as members of the Baghlan Group companies. The Baghlan Group website is registered at the same address as a division of the Transport Ministry.
At the same time, Baghlan Group companies have received lucrative, apparently noncompetitive contracts to import and operate taxis and buses, and to build roads. The contracts were all approved by the Transport Ministry.
"One of our fundamental objectives is to improve the country's transport infrastructure, including optimization of the local public transport system," Hafiz Mammadov states in a chairman's statement on the Baghlan Group website.
According to that website, the company owns the country's largest taxi company, which operates more than 1,000 London-style black cabs. The group's bus company is also the country's largest, with a fleet of "hundreds of buses" that carry over one-fifth of all bus passengers within Baku.
At a 2013 meeting chaired by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, Transport Minister Mammadov spoke of the need for 2,000 new taxis and 1,200 new buses. After Mammadov's presentation, Aliyev said: "We must approach this issue comprehensively. Of course we should update the vehicle fleet. We should bring in the new buses and taxis."
Baki Taxsi Takes Over
The London taxis were imported by the Baki Taxsi Company at a cost of $28,000 apiece, in time for the city to host the Eurovision 2012 Song Contest. Baki Taxsi proposed importing the taxis and the Transport Ministry agreed, Baki Taxsi director Ilqar Qasimov says. There is no evidence that any tenders were ever issued.
The Baki Taxsi Company was registered at the Tax Ministry in April 2010. The founder of the company is listed as Murad Farhad oglu Gasimov.
Baki Taxsi head Qasimov confirms that the company was actually established by the Baghlan Group, and that the Baghlan Group manages all the record-keeping and other official business for Baki Taxsi. Qasimov says there is a plan to import London taxis for use in other Azerbaijani cities.
Aliyev and Transport Minister Mammadov were quick to publicly praise the taxis as they appeared in busy quarters of Baku. But soon after the London taxis were imported, the Transport Ministry tightened regulations on other taxis. Ministry inspectors began forbidding other taxi drivers from parking in the city center and at subway stops, giving the Baghlan-owned company a significant competitive advantage. Some drivers protested, but to no avail.
Niyamaddin Imanov has been a taxi owner/operator for 10 years. He says it has been impossible to compete with the London taxis since they arrived and received preferential treatment from the Transport Ministry.
"First they told us that Soviet-made cars could no longer be taxis," says Imanov, who is currently driving a Daewoo model. "Then we were told we could no longer wait in our usual spots. We were told those spots were only for London taxis.
"Without giving us any reasons, the Ministry of Transport created obstacles for us in order to give more business to the London taxis."
The Preferred Bank
Qasimov says the point-of-sale terminals in each London taxi that allow passengers to pay their taxi fare by credit card belong to the Bank of Azerbaijan, which handles all transactions.
The taxi meters and Global Positioning System (GPS) devices in the London taxis belong to City Taxi LTD, which was established in 2008 by Nizami Aga oglu Rafiyev. The company shares the same official address (24 Hasan Aliyvev) as the Baghlan Group and several other companies involved in the transportation industry.
"Any taxis brought into the country have received a license and permission to operate from the Ministry of Transport," ministry spokesman Namik Hasanov said. "Nobody can bring these taxis without permission from the ministry." When asked about the selection process, Hasanov said, "The companies that offer the best terms and services are chosen."
Anar Mammadov, the son of the transport minister, was until recently listed as holding 81 percent of the shares in the Bank of Azerbaijan. The Bank of Azerbaijan has for some time been listed as a "part of the holding" on the Baghlan website. Bank of Azerbaijan documents from the Baku Stock Exchange showed that Baghlan founder Hafiz Mammadov was a member of the bank's supervisory board.
Anar Mammadov, the minister's son, has recently divested himself of his Bank of Azerbaijan shares. As of late January 2013, the new shareholders are family members of Baghlan Group owner Hafiz Mammadov, including son Kanan (43 percent), son Sanan (43 percent), and brother Mubariz (13 percent).
All In The Family
Anar Mammadov, who also serves as chairman of the board of directors of ZQAN Holding, a conglomerate that includes construction, hotel, and insurance companies, still has at least two key ties at the bank. Seymur Ismayil, chairman of the bank's supervisory board, is a senior manager at ZQAN Holding. Supervisory board member Ruslan Mammadov is a cousin of Anar Mammadov as well as his personal lawyer, according to several sources.
Among the properties listed under ZQAN Holding are the Meridian Hotel in Baku and the Azbentonit construction company. (Another ZQAN Holding company is the insurance firm Garant Sigorta, which is the insurer for passengers in London taxis.)
There are other companies belonging to Baghlan Group that also specialize in transportation and infrastructure. Arcon LTD, established in 2003, lists the Baku International Bus Station among its projects. ZQAN Holding participated in the construction of the bus station.
According to Aygun Gadirli, head of the CEO office at the Azerbaijani office of Baghlan Group, its Transgate subsidiary owns 500 of the 2,400 buses operating in Baku.
According to Transport Ministry spokesman Hasanov, the state has purchased 186 buses using almost $40 million in government funds and distributed the new buses among some the country's 50 bus companies.
"A total of 186 buses were purchased by the state at a cost of 30,445,000 AZN [about $38.8 million]," Hasanov said. Noting that there are about 50 bus companies in Azerbaijan, he said the ministry distributed the buses among several companies so there would not be a monopoly. But when asked exactly which companies received buses and how many, Hasanov said he couldn't give exact numbers.
Closed Connections
The website Baghlangroup.com is registered at the address Dilare Alieyva 230. That is also the official address of Azerbaijan State Railway LLC, a department in the Transport Ministry. It has significant contracts with the state railroad.
According to its website, "Baghlan Group is a leading freight agent for national railway and offers full range of transportations services, including planning, scheduling, handling, tracing, loading, unloading and logistics management for a range of rail cars as well as customs clearance. Full cargo transportation services within CIS and internationally along Silk Way from Eastern Asia to Western Europe for a number of local and multinational clients."
The company also is involved in highway construction for the ministry and has several government contracts worth 1 billion Azeri new manats (AZN), about $1.3 billion. According to Baghlan spokesman Gadirli, this includes "several small projects" on a major Transport Ministry plan to complete a 208-kilometer concrete road connecting Baku and the Russian border outpost at Samur.
Away from the business offices, Baghlan and the Mammadov family share a sporting interest. Baghlan sponsors the Baku Football Club and Baghlan founder Hafiz Mammadov is the club president. The minister's son, Anar Mammadov, is the honorary president of the club. Anar's ZQAN Holding, Bank of Azerbaijan, and Baghlan Group are all club sponsors.
Transport Ministry spokesman Hasanov was asked about all the ties between the two Mammadov families. "Only the interests of Azerbaijan are important to the minister," Hasanov said. "Maybe these businesses belong to someone close to the minister. If these people propose efficient and strong projects, why shouldn't they be preferred?
"I don't want to speak any more about it."
In the Azeri language, the word "baghlan" can mean "closed" or it can mean "connected." In the case of Baghlan Group, both seem to apply.
Transport Minister Ziya Mammadov's son, Anar, and the minister's brother, Elton, are business partners with the members of the family of the founder of the Baghlan Group, a prominent Azerbaijani company involved in major projects in transportation, construction, sports complexes, and oil exploration.
The Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project and Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty found that Baghlan was the contractor on a series of major initiatives by the ministry, including the importing of 1,000 London taxis to Baku, the construction of an international bus station, and a lucrative road-construction project.
The group has received preferential treatment and the interlinked companies owned by the families have taken large shares or even monopolized certain transportation sectors like bus transport, taxis, road construction, and cargo-transportation services in the country.
Businessman Hafiz Mammadov, who is not related to the minister, founded Baghlan Group FZCO, which was registered in 2007 in the United Arab Emirates. The ties between the families include co-ownership of the Bank of Azerbaijan and a joint project to build an international bus station in Baku. Both families also have top executives in the Baku Football Club. Companies owned by Anar Mammadov are also listed as members of the Baghlan Group companies. The Baghlan Group website is registered at the same address as a division of the Transport Ministry.
At the same time, Baghlan Group companies have received lucrative, apparently noncompetitive contracts to import and operate taxis and buses, and to build roads. The contracts were all approved by the Transport Ministry.
"One of our fundamental objectives is to improve the country's transport infrastructure, including optimization of the local public transport system," Hafiz Mammadov states in a chairman's statement on the Baghlan Group website.
According to that website, the company owns the country's largest taxi company, which operates more than 1,000 London-style black cabs. The group's bus company is also the country's largest, with a fleet of "hundreds of buses" that carry over one-fifth of all bus passengers within Baku.
At a 2013 meeting chaired by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, Transport Minister Mammadov spoke of the need for 2,000 new taxis and 1,200 new buses. After Mammadov's presentation, Aliyev said: "We must approach this issue comprehensively. Of course we should update the vehicle fleet. We should bring in the new buses and taxis."
Baki Taxsi Takes Over
The London taxis were imported by the Baki Taxsi Company at a cost of $28,000 apiece, in time for the city to host the Eurovision 2012 Song Contest. Baki Taxsi proposed importing the taxis and the Transport Ministry agreed, Baki Taxsi director Ilqar Qasimov says. There is no evidence that any tenders were ever issued.
The Baki Taxsi Company was registered at the Tax Ministry in April 2010. The founder of the company is listed as Murad Farhad oglu Gasimov.
Azerbaijani Transport Minister Ziya Mammadov (center) and Baghlan Group owner Hafiz Mammadov (behind him) present London taxis to President Ilham Aliyev (right).
Baki Taxsi head Qasimov confirms that the company was actually established by the Baghlan Group, and that the Baghlan Group manages all the record-keeping and other official business for Baki Taxsi. Qasimov says there is a plan to import London taxis for use in other Azerbaijani cities.
Aliyev and Transport Minister Mammadov were quick to publicly praise the taxis as they appeared in busy quarters of Baku. But soon after the London taxis were imported, the Transport Ministry tightened regulations on other taxis. Ministry inspectors began forbidding other taxi drivers from parking in the city center and at subway stops, giving the Baghlan-owned company a significant competitive advantage. Some drivers protested, but to no avail.
Niyamaddin Imanov has been a taxi owner/operator for 10 years. He says it has been impossible to compete with the London taxis since they arrived and received preferential treatment from the Transport Ministry.
"First they told us that Soviet-made cars could no longer be taxis," says Imanov, who is currently driving a Daewoo model. "Then we were told we could no longer wait in our usual spots. We were told those spots were only for London taxis.
"Without giving us any reasons, the Ministry of Transport created obstacles for us in order to give more business to the London taxis."
The Preferred Bank
Qasimov says the point-of-sale terminals in each London taxi that allow passengers to pay their taxi fare by credit card belong to the Bank of Azerbaijan, which handles all transactions.
The taxi meters and Global Positioning System (GPS) devices in the London taxis belong to City Taxi LTD, which was established in 2008 by Nizami Aga oglu Rafiyev. The company shares the same official address (24 Hasan Aliyvev) as the Baghlan Group and several other companies involved in the transportation industry.
"Any taxis brought into the country have received a license and permission to operate from the Ministry of Transport," ministry spokesman Namik Hasanov said. "Nobody can bring these taxis without permission from the ministry." When asked about the selection process, Hasanov said, "The companies that offer the best terms and services are chosen."
Ministry officials refused to accept taxi driver Elman Mammadov's tax receipts because he paid at the wrong bank.
The Baghlan-connected bank has monopolized almost all taxi business. All taxi drivers regardless of company must now pay their taxes and license fees only at the Bank of Azerbaijan branches. Elman Mammadov has been working as a taxi driver for 30 years. In November, he paid his taxes and licenses at another bank because it was more convenient. But Transport Ministry officials refused to accept his receipt because it wasn't paid at a Bank of Azerbaijan branch.Anar Mammadov, the son of the transport minister, was until recently listed as holding 81 percent of the shares in the Bank of Azerbaijan. The Bank of Azerbaijan has for some time been listed as a "part of the holding" on the Baghlan website. Bank of Azerbaijan documents from the Baku Stock Exchange showed that Baghlan founder Hafiz Mammadov was a member of the bank's supervisory board.
Anar Mammadov, the minister's son, has recently divested himself of his Bank of Azerbaijan shares. As of late January 2013, the new shareholders are family members of Baghlan Group owner Hafiz Mammadov, including son Kanan (43 percent), son Sanan (43 percent), and brother Mubariz (13 percent).
All In The Family
Anar Mammadov, who also serves as chairman of the board of directors of ZQAN Holding, a conglomerate that includes construction, hotel, and insurance companies, still has at least two key ties at the bank. Seymur Ismayil, chairman of the bank's supervisory board, is a senior manager at ZQAN Holding. Supervisory board member Ruslan Mammadov is a cousin of Anar Mammadov as well as his personal lawyer, according to several sources.
Among the properties listed under ZQAN Holding are the Meridian Hotel in Baku and the Azbentonit construction company. (Another ZQAN Holding company is the insurance firm Garant Sigorta, which is the insurer for passengers in London taxis.)
There are other companies belonging to Baghlan Group that also specialize in transportation and infrastructure. Arcon LTD, established in 2003, lists the Baku International Bus Station among its projects. ZQAN Holding participated in the construction of the bus station.
Anar Mammadov, president of ZQAN Holding and a minister's son, has his fingers in many pies.
According to records from the Tax Ministry, the bus station belongs to Baki XXI Esr MMC, a company established by Elton Mammadov, brother of Transport Minister Ziya Mammadov. Elton Mammadov confirmed he was the owner in an interview with RFE/RL.According to Aygun Gadirli, head of the CEO office at the Azerbaijani office of Baghlan Group, its Transgate subsidiary owns 500 of the 2,400 buses operating in Baku.
According to Transport Ministry spokesman Hasanov, the state has purchased 186 buses using almost $40 million in government funds and distributed the new buses among some the country's 50 bus companies.
"A total of 186 buses were purchased by the state at a cost of 30,445,000 AZN [about $38.8 million]," Hasanov said. Noting that there are about 50 bus companies in Azerbaijan, he said the ministry distributed the buses among several companies so there would not be a monopoly. But when asked exactly which companies received buses and how many, Hasanov said he couldn't give exact numbers.
Closed Connections
The website Baghlangroup.com is registered at the address Dilare Alieyva 230. That is also the official address of Azerbaijan State Railway LLC, a department in the Transport Ministry. It has significant contracts with the state railroad.
According to its website, "Baghlan Group is a leading freight agent for national railway and offers full range of transportations services, including planning, scheduling, handling, tracing, loading, unloading and logistics management for a range of rail cars as well as customs clearance. Full cargo transportation services within CIS and internationally along Silk Way from Eastern Asia to Western Europe for a number of local and multinational clients."
The company also is involved in highway construction for the ministry and has several government contracts worth 1 billion Azeri new manats (AZN), about $1.3 billion. According to Baghlan spokesman Gadirli, this includes "several small projects" on a major Transport Ministry plan to complete a 208-kilometer concrete road connecting Baku and the Russian border outpost at Samur.
Away from the business offices, Baghlan and the Mammadov family share a sporting interest. Baghlan sponsors the Baku Football Club and Baghlan founder Hafiz Mammadov is the club president. The minister's son, Anar Mammadov, is the honorary president of the club. Anar's ZQAN Holding, Bank of Azerbaijan, and Baghlan Group are all club sponsors.
Transport Ministry spokesman Hasanov was asked about all the ties between the two Mammadov families. "Only the interests of Azerbaijan are important to the minister," Hasanov said. "Maybe these businesses belong to someone close to the minister. If these people propose efficient and strong projects, why shouldn't they be preferred?
"I don't want to speak any more about it."
In the Azeri language, the word "baghlan" can mean "closed" or it can mean "connected." In the case of Baghlan Group, both seem to apply.