Accessibility links

Breaking News

China In Eurasia

Sorry! No content for 6 December. See content from before

Thursday 5 December 2024

Xi Jinping (left) looks on as Serbian President Aleksandr Vucic speaks at the Palace of Serbia on May 8 during the Chinese leader's two-day visit to Belgrade.
Xi Jinping (left) looks on as Serbian President Aleksandr Vucic speaks at the Palace of Serbia on May 8 during the Chinese leader's two-day visit to Belgrade.

BELGRADE -- Serbia has extradited five Chinese citizens in the last five years, according to data obtained by RFE/RL.

While one extradition case between China and Serbia was made public in 2021, the new instances, which were obtained by RFE/RL’s Balkan Service through a freedom-of-information request from the Serbian Justice Ministry, shows extraditions took place on a larger scale than previously known.

That cooperation is also set to grow as the Justice Ministry prepares to submit to parliament a draft extradition law with China that, if passed, would expand the scope of cooperation between Beijing and Belgrade.

In response to questions from RFE/RL, the Justice Ministry said it is currently writing the draft law and is "obtaining the opinions of other competent institutions." After that, the ministry said it "will initiate the procedure for ratification" of the treaty between Serbia and China.

The extradition agreement was signed in May during a state visit by Chinese leader Xi Jinping to Belgrade and is a sign of the deepening ties between the two countries. During that trip, Xi and Serbian President Aleksandr Vucic boosted their strong partnership with 28 new agreements, setting the stage for further cooperation in areas such as law enforcement and the media.

The extradition deal, which would regulate the bilateral extradition of citizens charged with crimes, is seen by experts as a response to the influx of tourists and Chinese nationals to Serbia that have corresponded with high-profile Chinese investments and loans for projects through Beijing’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).

A main thoroughfare in Belgrade decorated with Chinese and Serbian national flags ahead of Chinese President Xi Jinping's May 7-8 visit.
A main thoroughfare in Belgrade decorated with Chinese and Serbian national flags ahead of Chinese President Xi Jinping's May 7-8 visit.

According to data from Serbia's National Employment Service, more than 45,000 work permits have been issued to Chinese citizens since 2016, the year the ruling Serbian Progressive Party started intensifying relations with Beijing and expanding BRI projects.

Serbia’s Interior Ministry told RFE/RL there are currently 3,433 Chinese citizens registered in the country.

Petar Vidosavljevic, a lawyer at the Belgrade Center for Human Rights, a Belgrade-based NGO, tells RFE/RL that visa-free travel between the two countries has made it easier for Chinese to come to Serbia, including criminals.

But he added that questions remain over how Serbian "authorities will apply this agreement" and whether they will monitor it for instances of misuse.

Extradition Concerns

Beijing has faced criticism from watchdog groups for using the extradition system around the world to not only bring back criminals but also political dissidents and those from vulnerable groups, such as the country's Uyghur community.

The Madrid-based NGO Safeguard Defenders has warned about Beijing abusing the system.

The group says China has thus far signed more than 60 bilateral extradition treaties with countries around the world and more than 40 of them have been ratified by national parliaments.

A Belgrade billboard in April 2020 showing Chinese leader Xi Jinping says, “Thanks, Brother Xi.”
A Belgrade billboard in April 2020 showing Chinese leader Xi Jinping says, “Thanks, Brother Xi.”

And since Xi came to power in late 2012, Safeguard Defenders has recorded nearly 70 attempts by the Chinese government to have 400 people extradited to China. Most of them were in Europe and the extradition requests were deemed to be based on tenuous legal grounds.

Serbia has signed extradition treaties with numerous countries, such as the United States, Germany, Belarus, Turkey, Croatia, Montenegro, and Bosnia-Herzegovina.

But in the last five years, courts in more than a dozen European Union member states have stopped adhering to extradition requests from China, due to suspicion that the person whose extradition is sought would face repression, abuse, and extrajudicial retaliation back home.

A Serbian Snapshot

In the cases documented in the data obtained by RFE/RL about Serbia extraditing Chinese nationals, all five of the Chinese were pursued on criminal charges -- three on charges of fraud, one for money laundering, and one for inflicting serious bodily harm.

All five cases took place under Serbian domestic law that covers international criminal issues.

The new treaty, if ratified by parliament, could streamline that process, Vidosavljevic says. But he adds that with the contents of the deal signed in May not publicly available, there are concerns among human rights advocates as to whether all elements of the agreement will be disclosed.

The contract Serbia signed with China raised concern among human rights experts because it has still not been made public, Vidosavljevic adds.

Several contracts signed between Belgrade and the Chinese government or Chinese state-owned companies remain secret and came under scrutiny.

Most recently, there has been public backlash over the contracts with Chinese construction companies that renovated and rebuilt parts of the main railway station in the Serbian city of Novi Sad, whose roof collapsed and killed 15 people.

Serbian authorities said Chinese firms did not replace the roof that collapsed and that the contracts will not be publicly disclosed due to secrecy provisions in the deals.

Correction: The number of work permits issued to Chinese citizens since 2016 was previously stated incorrectly.
A Ukrainian officer points to a thermobaric charge from a downed Shahed drone launched by Russia from an undisclosed location in Ukraine.
A Ukrainian officer points to a thermobaric charge from a downed Shahed drone launched by Russia from an undisclosed location in Ukraine.

The European Union has proposed for the first time to target Chinese companies and individuals with visa bans and asset freezes over their dealings with Russian firms linked to Moscow's war effort in Ukraine, according to RFE/RL.

The new measures, which are laid out in a draft proposal reviewed by RFE/RL, are part of a proposed 15th sanctions package recently put forward by Brussels that aims to target six China-based companies with asset freezes and one Chinese citizen with a visa ban, among other entities.

While the EU has hit Chinese entities in the past with sanctions as part of Brussels' effort to curtail evasion, those measures have consisted of bans that prevent EU companies from having business dealings with those firms. This proposal marks the first effort to blacklist Chinese companies or individuals with visa bans and asset freezes over helping Russia procure dual-use goods that can be used on the battlefield.

If approved, such a move would prevent individuals associated with the company from entering the EU and would freeze each firm's EU-based funds.

The draft sanctions package comes as Russia has managed to overcome sweeping EU and U.S. technology sanctions aimed at stifling its military-industrial complex by rerouting crucial goods like microprocessors through friendly third countries or sourcing from them directly.

China, in particular, has played a leading role in boosting Russia's economy since its February 2022 invasion of Ukraine and Western officials have said that Chinese support in circumventing sanctions has had a major effect in helping Moscow on the battlefield.

The only Chinese individual proposed for a visa ban is a "Chinese businessperson" that represents a firm engaged in mainland China and Hong Kong, the draft document states, which has "infringed prohibitions against circumvention of the EU's restrictive measures regime imposed on the Russian Federation," including companies that are part of Russia's military-industrial complex.

The proposed document lists 54 persons for visa bans and 29 entities for asset freezes in total, the majority of which are based in Russia and are Russian citizens.

Among the six firms based in China or Hong Kong that are proposed for asset freezes, one of them is owned by a Russian national.

The company, the draft document states, "has been the largest supplier of sanctioned microelectronic components to Russian companies since the beginning of the war of aggression against Ukraine, which are used for the fabrication of Orlan drones which are used by the Russian military in Ukraine."

In addition to the asset freezes and visa bans, the new package also takes aim at 33 companies mostly based in Russia that are under export restrictions, but also includes firms based in China, Iran, Thailand, and the United Arab Emirates.

The document also lists 44 entities as part of an effort to impose sanctions on Russia's so-called "shadow fleet," the term meant to refer to ships that are engaged in illegal operations for the purposes of circumventing sanctions.

The draft version of the sanctions package was first shared with EU countries on November 22 and would still need to be approved by all 27 member states in order to come into effect.

Load more

About The Newsletter

In recent years, it has become impossible to tell the biggest stories shaping Eurasia without considering China’s resurgent influence in local business, politics, security, and culture.

Subscribe to this weekly dispatch in which correspondent Reid Standish builds on the local reporting from RFE/RL’s journalists across Eurasia to give you unique insights into Beijing’s ambitions and challenges.

To subscribe, click here.

RFE/RL has been declared an "undesirable organization" by the Russian government.

If you are in Russia or the Russia-controlled parts of Ukraine and hold a Russian passport or are a stateless person residing permanently in Russia or the Russia-controlled parts of Ukraine, please note that you could face fines or imprisonment for sharing, liking, commenting on, or saving our content, or for contacting us.

To find out more, click here.

XS
SM
MD
LG