Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

A Tatar parliamentary committee discusses the topic of the teaching of the Tatar language in Kazan in June.
A Tatar parliamentary committee discusses the topic of the teaching of the Tatar language in Kazan in June.

KAZAN, Russia -- Officials in Tatarstan are pushing back against calls to abandon teaching of the Tatar language in the Russian region's schools following comments by President Vladimir Putin about languages of ethnic minorities in the diverse country.

In a statement on September 7, the regional Education Ministry said that such calls "contradict federal and regional laws and mislead some parents."

The sensitive issue has triggered wide debate since Putin’s visit to the Republic of Mari El in July, when he suggested that ethnic Russians were being forced to learn these languages in regions with sizable minority populations.

The following month, he ordered federal prosecutors to check whether students in so-called ethnic republics were being forced to study minority languages across Russia.

In the oil-rich, Muslim-majority region of Tatarstan, the order sparked a series of rallies by non-Tatar parents who demanded that mandatory Tatar-language lessons in local schools be canceled.

But Tatarstan's regional Education Ministry hit back in its statement. It noted that the Russian Constitution gives all the republics within the Russian Federation the right to have their own state languages, and that Tatarstan's own constitution and law on state languages make the study of Russian and Tatar mandatory for all schools.

Among Tatarstan's population of almost 4 million, around half are Turkic-speaking Tatars, the majority of whom are fluent in Russian as well. The other half is comprised of Russians and other ethnic groups, including Udmurts, Bashkirs, and Chuvashes.

Russian President Boris Yeltsin (left) with Tatar President Mintimer Shaimiev in Moscow in 1997
Russian President Boris Yeltsin (left) with Tatar President Mintimer Shaimiev in Moscow in 1997

The escalating debate over the language issue in Tatarstan comes amid Kremlin hesitation to prolong a power-sharing treaty between the republic and the federal government in Moscow that expired several weeks ago.

The first power-sharing treaty was signed in 1994 by then-Russian President Boris Yeltsin and Tatarstan’s president at the time, Mintimer Shaimiev.

The treaty provided Tatarstan with broad autonomy, giving it rights to have its own laws, taxes, and even citizenship.

After Putin came to power in 2000, he began actively pursuing the creation of the so-called "power vertical" that many critics viewed as an attack on the principle of federalism itself.

Laws in the regions of the Russian Federation were brought into strict conformity with federal legislation. By 2005, all previous agreements and treaties between the regions and Moscow were annulled, and it was announced that pacts would be negotiated in conformity with strict new federal laws.

Special status was given to only two regions: Tatarstan and Chechnya.

Under a new treaty signed in 2007, Tatarstan was given the right to make decisions jointly with Moscow on the region's economic, cultural, and other policies.

Speaking in Mari El in July, Putin said it is "impermissible to force someone to learn a language that is not [his or her] mother tongue, as well as to cut the hours of Russian language [classes at schools] in Russia's ethnic republics."

His comments drew both criticism and praise online.

In recent years, some ethnic Russian residents of these regions have protested against mandatory classes in languages other than Russian.

In April, residents of Mari El, Tatarstan, and Chuvashia -- neighboring republics on the Volga River -- marked Language Day with a big campaign called I Speak My Mother Tongue!

Ivan Nepomnyashchikh speaks to reporters after being released from prison on August 24.
Ivan Nepomnyashchikh speaks to reporters after being released from prison on August 24.

The last Russian activist imprisoned following clashes at a protest on the eve of President Vladimir Putin's inauguration in 2012 has left the country after serving his 30-month sentence.

The nongovernmental organization Public Verdict said in a Facebook post on September 7 that Ivan Nepomnyashchikh, 27, had landed in Prague and planned to travel on to the United States, where he intends to study.

Nepomnyashchikh left a prison in a region northeast of Moscow on August 24 directly from solitary confinement, where he had been placed several days prior to his release.

But a court ruled that for three years after his release Nepomnyashchikh needed permission to leave the Moscow Oblast, the region that surrounds but does not include the capital. That decision was under appeal by Public Verdict at the time Nepomnyashchikh left the country.

"We were in constant contact from the moment he arrived at the airport until takeoff," his lawyer, Irina Biryukova, told the Moscow-based rights watchdog OVD-Info.

Biryukova added that a court hearing on the conditions of her client's release -- including restrictions on his movement -- was scheduled for September 8. The earlier court decision also forbids Nepomnyashchikh from participating in street protests for three years.

Nepomnyashchikh is the last activist to be convicted so far in connection with a May 6, 2012, rally on Moscow's Bolotnaya Square, where police detained more than 400 people after clashes that police and demonstrators blame on one another.

The rally was one of a series of large opposition protests sparked mainly by anger over electoral fraud and dismay at Putin's decision to return to the presidency after a four-year stint as prime minister.

More than 30 people were prosecuted in connection with the clashes and more than 20 were sentenced to prison or served time in pretrial custody.

Amnesty International has said that the police action at the rally "was not the quelling of a riot but the crushing of a protest" and that all those prosecuted are "victims of a politically motivated show trial."

One Bolotnaya protester, Maksim Panfilov, has been committed to a psychiatric hospital in the southern city of Astrakhan.

Dmitry Buchenkov, who is currently on trial in Moscow on charges of assaulting police during the Bolotnaya protest, says that he was not even there.

With reporting by ovdinfo.org

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Latest Posts

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG