Accessibility links

Breaking News

Watchdog

A number of Uzbek media outlets and journalists have been warned about how they portray Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
A number of Uzbek media outlets and journalists have been warned about how they portray Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Uzbekistan’s state media has been extremely careful covering the war in Ukraine, describing the conflict as a Russian “military operation” and refraining from calling it an “invasion” or “aggression.”

Independent publications and bloggers, meanwhile, have been warned by security services to be “very neutral” and to exercise “restraint” when writing about the war.

Several Uzbek bloggers and journalists who have written extensively about it since it began on February 24 said they came under state pressure because of their work.

Some of them claim they were interrogated by intelligence officers, while others were ordered to delete some of their work.

One blogger told RFE/RL on condition of anonymity that he was summoned by the State Security Services on February 28.

“They told me: ‘This is a very sensitive topic therefore you must be very neutral in your coverage of these events,’” he said.

By being “neutral,” authorities want the journalists to refrain from criticizing Russia, a major strategic partner of Uzbekistan.

Uzbek President Shavkat Mirziyoev and his government have not publicly condemned Russia’s unprovoked war.

'Incorrect' Coverage

A Telegram channel Haqiqat Vazirligi (truth ministry) wrote on March 2 that the government wants Uzbek media to follow the official line.

“Journalists and bloggers who cover this topic ‘incorrectly’ have been summoned by authorities to the State Security Service’s detention facility on Tashkent’s Gvardeyskaya Street, where they receive ‘recommendations’ on how to cover these events,” Haqiqat Vazirligi wrote.

Among those who were called by the security agency were editors and managers of the popular kun.uz online publication. They were interrogated on February 26.

“It’s not cool to be called to Gvardeyskaya on a Saturday,” Umid Shermuhammedov, a founder of kun.uz, wrote on social media. “They summoned one of our correspondents, one of my deputies, then my business partner, and now they’re waiting for me.”

Uzbek journalist Umid Shermuhammedov's social media post, which has since been deleted.
Uzbek journalist Umid Shermuhammedov's social media post, which has since been deleted.

Shermuhammedov said the authorities couldn’t initially reach him because he wasn’t in the city at the time.

Shermuhammedov added that he “hoped it will only be the usual prophylactic chat,” referring to Uzbek officials' practice of warning independent journalists against writing on a certain topic that does not sit well with the authoritarian government.

“But if I disappear for a day or two -- well, that’s [because] freedom of speech is barely standing on its feet,” he added.

Shermuhammedov later deleted his post and neither he nor kun.uz has since mentioned their conversations with the security officers.

Disappearing Articles

But RFE/RL sources say during the interrogation at the State Security Service offices kun.uz received a warning regarding its coverage of the conflict in Ukraine.

Meanwhile, several articles on the war in Ukraine have disappeared from Uzbek media sites.

A screengrab showing daryo.uz's article about flowers being left at the Ukrainian Embassy in Tashkent.
A screengrab showing daryo.uz's article about flowers being left at the Ukrainian Embassy in Tashkent.

One such article was on daryo.uz that reported about how Uzbeks were laying flowers near the Ukrainian Embassy in Tashkent to show their solidarity with the Ukrainian people. Daryo.uz didn’t say why it removed the report it published on February 26. But the story reappeared on the site late on March 8.

RFE/RL tried to contact officials in Tashkent for comment but didn’t receive a response.

Both state and independent media’s coverage of the war in Ukraine is now limited to carefully worded news of evacuations of Uzbeks from the war zone, certain aspects of the international sanctions on Russia, such as the fall of the ruble and its impact on Central Asia, and reports on the international package of financial aid for Ukraine.

The Uzbek media also occasionally shares photos from international news agencies depicting scenes from Ukraine.

Written by Farangis Najibullah based on reporting by RFE/RL Uzbek Service correspondent Khurmat Babadjanov.
Riot police detain demonstrators during a protest in St. Petersburg against Russia's war on Ukraine. For years, rights groups have sought to track the abuse and torture of detainees by Russian security forces and a new surreptitious recording seems to convey in painful detail how police interrogations are frequently conducted.
Riot police detain demonstrators during a protest in St. Petersburg against Russia's war on Ukraine. For years, rights groups have sought to track the abuse and torture of detainees by Russian security forces and a new surreptitious recording seems to convey in painful detail how police interrogations are frequently conducted.

The first blow comes about 52 seconds in, after Aleksandra Kaluzhskikh enters the interrogation room at the police station in the Moscow district of Brateyevo.

One of nearly 5,000 people arrested on March 6 amid protests against Russia’s war in Ukraine, Kaluzhskikh was asked to state her name, home address, and place of study, and to explain how she heard about the demonstrations.

In an audio recording first published by a well-known Russian rights group and circulated on a Telegram channel, Kaluzhskikh, 26, responds by citing the clause in the Russian Constitution that bars people from incriminating themselves.

The sound of what appears to be a person being hit is then heard.

“The next one will be even harder,” a man identified in the transcript as a police officer can be heard saying.

It gets worse.

Over nearly 11 minutes of the recording, the sound of blows is heard repeatedly, interspersed with verbal abuse.

By the standards of Russian police brutality, documented for years by rights groups, the physical and verbal abuse that Kaluzhskikh endured is shocking, but not out of the ordinary.

WATCH: Russian Police Brutally Disperse Peaceful Protests (August 2019)

No One Safe As Moscow Police Lash Out
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:02:58 0:00

The fact that it was recorded, apparently surreptitiously, was unusual and revelatory, conveying in painful detail how police interrogations are frequently conducted -- and the violence that is frequently employed.

Kaluzhskikh could not be immediately located for comment and her whereabouts were not immediately clear. OVD-Info, the nongovernmental organization that published the audio recording, said it did so with Kaluzhskikh’s permission. Other media outlets, including the newspaper Novaya gazeta, also obtained the recording.

The group did not immediately respond to a query from RFE/RL, and the authenticity of the recording could not be independently verified. There was no immediate response to an e-mail query sent to the main Moscow police department mailing address.

Heavy Riot Police Response

The expletive-laden recording, which was also published to YouTube, appeared on the same day of anti-war protests in Moscow and dozens of other Russian cities -- the 11th day of Russia’s unprovoked invasion of Ukraine. Numbers of participants in the protests were unclear, and in many cases, the protesters were met with a heavy riot police response.

Thousands Detained In Anti-War Protests Across Russia
please wait

No media source currently available

0:00 0:01:24 0:00

OVD-Info said that more than 2,000 people were detained in Moscow on March 6, and more than 4,600 nationwide. Official police figures put the number at around 3,300.

Rights groups for years have sought to track the abuse and torture of detainees, not only by police but also in Russia’s prison system.

Last year, a former prison inmate managed to copy and smuggle out scores of videos showing abuse in Russian prisons. The revelation caused a stir, and outrage, among Russians who, in many cases, have become inured to the systematic nature of the problem.

The recording obtained by OVD-Info begins as Kaluzhskikh is brought into an undetermined room; the sounds of several police officers -- male and female -- can be heard speaking to her.

After she refuses to answer the officers’ questions, and she cites “Article 51” of the constitution, she is hit repeatedly. And she can be heard swearing repeatedly.

'Putin Is On Our Side'

At one point, after an officer is heard mocking her anatomy and her appearance, Kaluzhskikh asks if the officer is threatening her.

“Yes. I’m threatening you. I’m threatening you with physical violence,” he says.

“Putin is on our side. You are the enemies of Russia. You are the enemies of the people,” the same officer is heard saying later.

It’s not clear how long in all Kaluzhskikh endured police questioning or abuse. At one point in the recording, she can be heard saying, “We have been here for more than three hours.”

At another point, a female officer or interrogator accuses her of being crazy, apparently due to her refusal to answer the questioning -- and citing her legal rights.

“A man beats me up in front of you and I’m [crazy]?!” Kaluzhskikh responds.

The recording cuts off after a conversation about her broken cell phone, and then is followed by muffled sounds of movement and a woman crying.

A Twitter account belonging to a group of feminist activists also posted a message on March 6 saying that at least three women who had been detained at the same police precinct had been beaten by officers, with one of them having her hair pulled and another having a bag put over her head.

In an interview with the Telegram channel known as SOTA, published late on March 6, Kaluzhskikh explained further what happened.

"They kicked me, slapped me on the head.” she was quoted as saying. “They poured water on me. They ripped off my mask, ripped the phone out of my hands, threw it against the wall, twice.”

“At the end, they picked [the phone] up, wiped off the fingerprints. They grabbed me by the hair and pulled me around,” she said, according to SOTA. “They called me names. There were two girls in the office, and they were just watching the torture.”

Load more

About This Blog

"Watchdog" is a blog with a singular mission -- to monitor the latest developments concerning human rights, civil society, and press freedom. We'll pay particular attention to reports concerning countries in RFE/RL's broadcast region.

Subscribe

Latest Posts

Journalists In Trouble

RFE/RL journalists take risks, face threats, and make sacrifices every day in an effort to gather the news. Our "Journalists In Trouble" page recognizes their courage and conviction, and documents the high price that many have paid simply for doing their jobs. More

XS
SM
MD
LG